跨组织/性别系统评估曼氏无针乌贼内参基因的稳定性

Systematic evaluation of reference gene stability across tissues and sexes in cuttlefish (Sepiella japonica)

  • 摘要:
    目的 系统评估曼氏无针乌贼雌雄个体多种组织中五个常用内参基因(18Sef-1αef-1γgapdhβ-actin)的表达稳定性,筛选适用于实时荧光定量PCR(qPCR)分析的最佳内参基因及其数量。
    方法 采集10尾健康曼氏无针乌贼(雌雄各5尾)的15~16种组织,提取总RNA并反转录为cDNA。通过qPCR检测基因表达,结合GeNorm、NormFinder、BestKeeper和ΔCt四种算法及RefFinder综合评价基因稳定性,利用GeNorm配对变异分析(Vn/n+1 < 0.15)确定最佳内参基因数量。选取4个转录组来源的靶基因(creld2、cd109、acy1、miox)进行验证。
    结果 五个基因Ct值范围为15.47–20.83,β-actingapdh在组织及性别间波动最大,不宜作为通用内参;18S表达量最高(Ct均值:15.47~16.29),变异最小,但存在性别偏倚表达;ef-1αef-1γ在多数组织和两个性别中表现出较高的稳定性,其中ef-1α表达最稳定,无任何性别偏倚。虽然各基因在不同组织和性别间的稳定性模式及具体排名存在差异,但多算法综合结果表明,ef-1αef-1γ整体稳定性最高,其次为18S,而β-actingapdh稳定性最低,在雌雄中的最终排名为:ef-1γ > ef-1α > 18S > gapdh > β-actin(雄);ef-1α > ef-1γ > 18S > gapdh > β-actin(雌)。GeNorm分析显示,多数组织使用两个内参基因(主要为ef-1αef-1γ)即可满足归一化要求(V2/3 < 0.15)。验证实验表明,使用稳定内参组合(ef-1αef-1γ)能准确反映组织间表达差异,而使用不稳定内参基因组合(β-actingapdh)则导致多数靶基因失去统计显著性。
    结论 ef-1αef-1γ是曼氏无针乌贼qPCR分析中最适宜的内参基因组合,18S可作为辅助基因用于性别内比较,避免单独使用β-actingapdh。本研究首次建立了曼氏无针乌贼内参基因选择的系统化框架,为后续曼氏无针乌贼及其他头足类基因表达研究提供了可靠参考。

     

    Abstract:
    Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) is widely used for gene expression analysis, but its accuracy critically depends on stable internal reference genes for normalization. In marine invertebrates, especially non-model taxa such as cephalopods, systematic evaluation of reference genes is limited, leading to potential bias. The cuttlefish Sepiella japonica is ecologically and economically important in China, yet previous molecular studies have often relied on single unvalidated reference genes, which may compromise data reliability. To systematically evaluate the stability of five commonly used reference genes (18S, ef-1α, ef-1γ, gapdh, and β-actin) across multiple tissues and sexes of S. japonica, and to identify the most suitable reference genes and optimal number for qPCR normalization. Fifteen to sixteen tissue types were collected from ten healthy adults (five males and five females). Total RNA was extracted, reverse-transcribed, and analyzed by qPCR. Gene stability was assessed using four algorithms (GeNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and ΔCt) integrated with RefFinder, and the optimal gene number was determined using GeNorm pairwise variation (Vn/n+1 < 0.15). Four transcriptome-derived genes (creld2, cd109, acy1, and miox) were used for validation. The Ct values of the five genes ranged from 15.47 to 20.83. β-actin and gapdh showed pronounced variability in expression stability among tissues and sexes, underscoring their limited suitability for normalization. 18S exhibited the highest expression (mean Ct: 15.47–16.29) and lowest variability but displayed sex-biased expression, whereas ef-1α and ef-1γ remained consistently stable across most tissues in both sexes, with ef-1α being the most robust and showing no sex-related bias. Although specific rankings varied among tissues and sexes, the comprehensive results indicated that ef-1α and ef-1γ possessed the highest overall stability, followed by 18S, while β-actin and gapdh were the least stable. The final comprehensive rankings were ef-1γ > ef-1α > 18S > gapdh > β-actin (male) and ef-1α > ef-1γ > 18S > gapdh > β-actin (female). GeNorm analysis (V2/3 < 0.15) indicated that two genes, mainly ef-1α and ef-1γ, were generally sufficient for reliable normalization in most tissues. Validation confirmed that normalization using stable ef-1α and ef-1γ accurately reflect the expression differences among tissues, whereas β-actin and gapdh can bias or confound statistical analyses.
    Conclusion ef-1α and ef-1γ are identified as the most reliable reference gene combination for qPCR analysis in S. japonica, while 18S can serve as an auxiliary gene for within-sex comparisons. The use of β-actin or gapdh alone is not recommended. This study establishes a systematic framework for selecting reliable reference genes in S. japonica, thereby facilitating robust qPCR normalization and providing a foundation for future gene expression research in S. japonica and other cephalopods.

     

/

返回文章
返回