草鱼、鲢和鳙盐度与碱度急性耐受及短期驯养效应比较

Comparison of acute salinity and alkalinity tolerance and short-term acclimation effects in Ctenopharyngodon idella, Hypophthalmichthys molitrix, and Hypophthalmichthys nobilis

  • 摘要:
    目的 比较1龄草鱼、鳙和鲢对盐度与碱度的急性耐受差异,评价短期驯养对后续胁迫存活率的影响。
    方法 以草鱼(114.56 ± 2.29) g、鳙(117.45 ± 2.66) g和鲢(159.45 ± 1.87) g为对象,分别开展NaCl盐度和NaHCO3碱度96 h急性耐受实验,计算24、48和96 h半致死浓度(LC50)及估算安全浓度(SC);另设置96 h短期驯养后-48 h存活率实验,比较不同短期驯养浓度下对盐度和碱度耐受性的影响。
    结果 草鱼、鳙和鲢的盐度估算安全浓度分别为3.20、3.67和4.00 g/L,耐盐能力为鲢>鳙>草鱼;碱度估算安全浓度分别为22.27、17.69和11.72 mmol/L,耐碱能力为草鱼>鳙>鲢。盐度短期驯养后,草鱼2.98和3.96 g/L组的存活率与未驯化组差异不显著,而6.01 g/L组显著降低;鳙3.13 g/L组的存活率显著高于未驯化组,而4.09和6.19 g/L组显著降低;鲢各驯养组的存活率均显著高于未驯化组,但最高驯养浓度下存活率有所下降。碱度短期驯养后,草鱼17.30和23.21 mmol/L组的存活率均显著高于未驯化组,而34.55 mmol/L组显著降低;鳙14.45 mmol/L组的存活率显著高于未驯化组,其他驯养组差异不显著;鲢各驯养组的存活率均显著高于未驯化组,但随驯养浓度升高总体呈下降趋势。
    结论 三种鱼对盐度和碱度表现出不同的急性耐受水平,短期驯养后的存活率呈现鱼种和浓度依赖特征。本研究结果可为三种鱼的急性耐受评价和短期驯养条件筛选提供基础数据,长期养殖适用性及其生理机制仍需进一步验证。

     

    Abstract: Inland saline-alkaline waters provide potential space for expanding aquaculture, but elevated salinity and carbonate alkalinity can impose strong osmotic and acid-base stress on freshwater fish. This study compared the acute tolerance of one-year-old Ctenopharyngodon idella (114.56 ± 2.29) g, Hypophthalmichthys nobilis (117.45 ± 2.66) g, and Hypophthalmichthys molitrix (159.45 ± 1.87) g to salinity and alkalinity, and evaluated whether short-term fixed-concentration acclimation affected survival during a subsequent challenge. Separate 96-h acute tolerance tests were conducted using NaCl for salinity and NaHCO3 for alkalinity. The 24, 48, and 96 h median lethal concentrations (LC50) were estimated from measured exposure concentrations and mortality, and safe concentrations (SC) were calculated using an empirical acute-toxicity equation. In a separate acclimation–challenge experiment, fish were acclimated for 96 h to approximately one-quarter, one-third, or one-half of the species-specific 96-h LC50 and were then challenged for 48 h at a concentration close to the corresponding 96-h LC50. The estimated safe salinity concentrations for C. idella, H. nobilis, and H. molitrix were 3.20, 3.67, and 4.00 g/L, respectively, indicating a salinity-tolerance ranking of H. molitrix > H. nobilis > C. idella. The estimated safe alkalinity concentrations were 22.27, 17.69, and 11.72 mmol/L, respectively, with an alkalinity-tolerance ranking of C. idella > H. nobilis > H. molitrix. During the salinity challenge, survival of C. idella acclimated at 2.98 and 3.96 g/L did not differ significantly from that of the unacclimated group, whereas survival at 6.01 g/L was significantly lower. In H. nobilis, survival in the 3.13 g/L acclimation group was significantly higher than that in the unacclimated group, whereas survival in the 4.09 and 6.19 g/L groups was significantly lower. In H. molitrix, survival in all acclimation groups was significantly higher than that in the unacclimated group, although survival decreased at the highest acclimation concentration. During the alkalinity challenge, survival of C. idella in the 17.30 and 23.21 mmol/L acclimation groups was significantly higher than that in the unacclimated group, whereas survival in the 34.55 mmol/L group was significantly lower. In H. nobilis, survival in the 14.45 mmol/L acclimation group was significantly higher than that in the unacclimated group, whereas no significant differences were observed at 19.25 and 28.90 mmol/L. In H. molitrix, survival in all three acclimation groups was significantly higher than that in the unacclimated group, but generally decreased with increasing acclimation concentration. These results show that the three species differ in their acute tolerance to salinity and alkalinity and that the effects of short-term acclimation on subsequent challenge survival are species- and concentration-dependent. The results provide baseline data for acute tolerance assessment and short-term acclimation design, while their applicability to long-term culture and the underlying physiological mechanisms require further validation.

     

/

返回文章
返回